Civic Issues
Topics getting the most attention in Shaker Heights public meetings, ranked by how frequently they are discussed.
41 issues in public safety
Flock license plate reader contract
A resident pressed Council on unresolved privacy questions from 2023 — warrantless searches, data sharing, mission creep — and urged canceling the Flock contract. The mayor said the review continues and the matter will return to Council.
Fire battalion chief and lieutenant promotion process
A testing company, exam weights, and a cap on lieutenant candidates advancing to the assessment center were all on the agenda — the building blocks of who rises through fire department leadership ranks.
Firefighter entry-level hiring pipeline
The Commission was scheduled to certify the eligibility list from the fire entry-level exam, which drew 111 applications. Certification is the step that lets the department move toward hiring new firefighters, expected in early 2027.
Shaker Heights Municipal Court update
Judge Anne Keller was scheduled to brief council on the state of the Shaker Heights Municipal Court. The court handles local traffic, misdemeanor, and civil cases, so its operations, staffing, and caseload directly affect residents who interact with the local justice system.
Animal control and kenneling services
The city's longtime animal control vendor — handling dead wildlife pickup and dog kenneling — is the only company that bid on the five-year contract, at $550,925 total.
2026–2031 Animal Control RFP
The city is putting out a request for proposals for animal control services through 2031. This shapes how residents get help with animal issues for years to come.
Police vehicle upfitting contract
After years of problems with other vendors, police will use Fallsway Equipment as their sole cruiser upfitter for two years, about $25,000 per car for roughly 10 vehicles.
FOP Gold Unit labor agreement (2025-2027)
Shaker Heights has finalized its contract with police sergeants and lieutenants after a contentious negotiation that went to state fact-finding. The deal costs about $207,761 over three years and includes raises of roughly 4% then 3.5% a year, plus new benefits like paid parental leave. The patrol officers' contract is still up in the air.
Police Oversight
An independent investigation cleared the Shaker Heights police chief of most misconduct claims, helping put a messy department drama to rest. It's a big relief for local leadership, but it definitely leaves some residents wondering about true police accountability.
Golf course mowing noise and proposed crosswalk island
One resident complained about 6:30 a.m. mowing at the golf course and opposed a pedestrian island near the Van Aken hub she believes would reward jaywalking.
SEIU organizers cited at Bellefaire JCB picket
Two union organizers said police cited them for disturbing the peace at their final Bellefaire JCB picket without warning, and asked whether the city is protecting workers or corporate interests. Council members pointed them to the formal complaint process.
Elevator issues affecting tenants with disabilities
The board was scheduled to discuss how elevator problems impact tenants with disabilities. Reliable elevators are essential for residents with mobility limitations to access their homes. No record of the discussion or any action is available.
Fall fair housing training
The board was scheduled to report on past and future education and outreach, including possible landlord trainings and tenant-focused sessions.
Housing nuisance appeal — 20013 Scottsdale Boulevard
Wendy Newberry appealed a housing nuisance notice for her property at 20013 Scottsdale Boulevard. The Board of Appeals was scheduled to hold a public hearing on the appeal; the outcome would determine whether the nuisance notice stands.
Human Resources records retention schedule update
The city updates how long it keeps HR records before archiving or destroying them. This affects what employment-related records exist if residents or journalists ever request them.
Police Lateral Eligibility List changes
The commission was asked to consider removing certain candidates from the lateral entry eligibility list used to hire experienced officers.
Senior Well Call program
The City is building a volunteer program making daily wellness phone calls to isolated seniors, partnering with Meals on Wheels, the library, Parks and Rec, and EMS data to find those who need help.
Bulk item pickup program
Residents will soon be able to schedule free backyard pickup of up to three large items like furniture and appliances. The pilot runs August 1 through October 31, 2026; from 2027, two free pickups per year with $150 for extras, plus quarterly Service Center drop-offs.
Cooling Center Availability During Extreme Heat
Council member Chengelis asked whether residents had asked about cooling centers during the recent heat wave. Police and the administration reported no such requests.
Firefighter Health and Safety — Gear Cleaning Equipment
The fire department's 30-year-old washers and dryers for turnout gear are near the end of their life. Gear washed promptly removes carcinogens that would otherwise be reabsorbed through firefighters' skin. A FEMA grant would cover 90% of the $75,000 replacement cost.
Brush and Grass Bag Collection Changes
Public Works now lets brush crews pick up grass bags early when already on the street — an added service, not a replacement for regular rubbish-day collection. The city is sending clearer guidance after one resident's confusion.
Firefighter Annual Medical Examinations
The city will contract with Cleveland Clinic AtWork for yearly medical exams for all firefighters, as required by the collective bargaining agreement. The exams include cancer screenings and cardiovascular testing, both major health risks in the fire service.
Police entry-level hiring and declining applicant pool
Only 35 people applied for the police entry exam this year, down from 254 in 2013, and 25 took the test. The commission was scheduled to set the passing grade and certify the eligibility list so the department can hire for August academy seats. A shrinking pipeline means slower police staffing.
Replacement Lifepak cardiac monitors for Fire Department
The city's five cardiac monitors are at the end of their ten-year life; new Lifepak 35 units can transmit patient data straight to hospital ERs and cath labs.
Replacement of two totaled police cruisers
Two cruisers wrecked in 2025 will be replaced with $102,000 in insurance proceeds, though upfitting costs of $18,000-$20,000 per vehicle come from the department budget.
Summer Youth Police Academy
The police chief pitched the eight-day academy for 14- to 18-year-olds as preventive public-safety investment — building trust and teaching young people how to handle police encounters before problems arise.
E-bike regulation gaps
Shaker Heights has no standalone e-bike ordinances; some higher-powered e-bikes may fall under existing motorized vehicle code. The Law Department will clarify and share ordinances with council.
Traffic signal power failures during storms
The recent storm knocked out power at major intersections, requiring officers to hook patrol-vehicle inverters to signals. Police are exploring battery backup systems that would keep signals running automatically.
Police Federal Trust Fund Spending
Asset-forfeiture dollars will buy the Cellebrite phone-data extraction system, IA Pro transparency reporting software and virtual reality training. Council pressed on data privacy — data stays on a locked, standalone drive with no vendor access, and extractions require warrants or consent.
Remote meeting attendance and citizen inquiry process
Council kept its remote-attendance rules intact and deferred a proposal to standardize how resident inquiries are routed and answered, after members raised privacy and definition concerns.
Police community engagement funding
$100,000 in federal asset-forfeiture funds will pay for community policing programs — the Citizens Academy, Teen Summit, National Night Out, juvenile prevention partnerships, and a new focus on seniors.
Police Misconduct Lawsuit
Shaker Heights is facing a high-stakes police misconduct lawsuit that ropes in the police chief. It's a messy situation for city leadership that could lead to some serious accountability questions.
Police Conduct Investigation
Local news has uncovered on-duty videos taken by a Shaker Heights police officer, raising serious questions about how well the department is being run and whether anyone is watching the watchers. This could lead to a major shake-up in how the city holds its police force accountable.
Building & Housing Department operations
The committee was scheduled to hear an overview of the Building & Housing Department, which handles permits, inspections, and property maintenance — services residents interact with when renovating or reporting property issues.
Police Forfeiture Funds and Ballistic Vest Plates
The police department wants rifle-rated vest plates ($25,000 from seized drug funds) because current plates only stop handgun rounds and AR-15-style rifles are increasingly on the streets. One member raised data-privacy questions about the Cellebrite phone-extraction tool that remain unresolved.
Blue Envelope Program
Shaker Heights police are joining a statewide program that gives drivers with autism, dementia, or anxiety a blue envelope for their documents, signaling officers to use a calmer approach during traffic stops. Launch is expected within weeks.
City building safety assessment
Shaker is spending $45,250 to audit nine city buildings — including City Hall, both fire stations, and the rec center — for hazards after recent accidents. As a self-insured city, it lost the free state safety audits it once got.
Lee-Scottsdale Building facade repair
Loose masonry at 3756 Lee Road means the protective fencing stays up for years. FirstEnergy needs six months just to design a power-line move, and no work can happen within ten feet of the lines. Historic tax credits may help fund rehab.
Lawsuit Against Police Chief
Shaker Heights is facing a major headache after a new lawsuit was filed against the police chief, which is raising serious red flags about city leadership and potential fallout. This could lead to some messy public drama and shake things up at city hall.
School Safety Outreach Following Student Letter
A letter from an Onaway School student raised safety concerns and asked families to use security cameras. Council Member Kaus suggested city outreach to the school, and police will begin monthly visits to every school starting January 1.
Rescue Squad Donations to Neighboring Communities
Shaker Heights has spare rescue squads after finally getting delivery of a new 2025 unit. Donating the 2009 and 2014 vehicles to Maple Heights and Oakwood skips about $10,000 in sale proceeds but strengthens regional EMS coverage for everyone.