Public Safety

Immigration ordinance

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Supportive (7)Opposed (12)Neutral (3)

At a glance

Public comments
22
Last 30 days
0

Last discussed Mar 2, 2026.

Public comments (22)

SupportiveJennifer SederMar 2, 2026

Argued ICE doesn't act like normal law enforcement and the city could be held liable for their actions; urged support for the ordinance.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 4:59 →
OpposedRicky ThomasMar 2, 2026

A 26-year military veteran and retired teacher who chose Sylvania; asked Council to deny the ordinance and trust Police Chief Miller's existing policies.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 6:34 →
OpposedKen MarciniakMar 2, 2026

45-year resident who agreed police should work with all governmental agencies and warned against trusting TV coverage; opposed the ordinance.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 8:19 →
OpposedBarbara ShaffnerMar 2, 2026

Retired Miami law enforcement officer; warned against Sylvania backing away from mutual aid with ICE and township officers.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 9:42 →
SupportiveConstance ShawlMar 2, 2026

Argued the ordinance focuses city resources on city services, that due process protects all persons, and urged its passage.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 11:32 →
SupportiveValdimar VelasquezMar 2, 2026

With the Farm Labor Organizing Committee; cited the 1971 Putnam County raid and urged passage to protect due process and community trust.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 13:51 →
SupportiveJoe MoranMar 2, 2026

Vietnam veteran and retired chief probation officer who called ICE a knee-jerk fix and opposed local police doing federal immigration work.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 16:42 →
SupportivePatty Barnes WalcherMar 2, 2026

Invoked Sylvania's Underground Railroad history at the Lathrop House; asked the city to not use its resources for federal enforcement.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 19:03 →
OpposedAbby BrutlingerMar 2, 2026

Opposed the ordinance as written, saying its mutual aid language is gray, could put officers in a box, and might signal safety risks to businesses and taxpayers.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 21:07 →
NeutralIrene RoseMar 2, 2026

Requested a plain-language recap of the ordinance for newcomers before commenting.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 22:45 →
OpposedBrenda ThomasMar 2, 2026

Lifelong resident worried the ordinance would make her sisters reconsider retiring in Sylvania; urged cooperation with federal agencies.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 23:38 →
SupportiveSteve BenchmanMar 2, 2026

Cited a Spokane lawsuit costing $49,000 over Lexipol immigration policy; favored the ordinance and continued research.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 25:38 →
OpposedDan RichardsonMar 2, 2026

Asked what lawsuit the city would face if it ends ICE cooperation and a resident is harmed; called resource concerns a 'lie'.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 27:37 →
OpposedTim BrentMar 2, 2026

Warned of 'unintended consequences' — sanctuary-community lists driving up housing and school costs; urged a no vote.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 29:29 →
OpposedRiley KerriganMar 2, 2026

Said the police have safety covered and ICE presence is needed to keep Sylvania safe.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 30:58 →
OpposedJohn HillMar 2, 2026

Blamed the prior federal administration for immigration strains and said those here illegally should get paperwork or go home.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 31:56 →
OpposedCharles MooreMar 2, 2026

Fourth-generation resident and concrete contractor; said it isn't a money issue and the department should be allowed to do its job.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 32:49 →
SupportiveDevin BodaiMar 2, 2026

Argued non-citizens contribute more in taxes than they take and called ICE unaccountable; urged passage of the ordinance.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 34:42 →
NeutralNatalie MorganMar 2, 2026

Challenged each council member to name what evidence would change their vote — and warned that if the answer is 'nothing,' they aren't representing citizens.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 37:17 →
OpposedBill TaranskyMar 2, 2026

Sylvania Township resident who said withholding support from ICE endangers officers and could invite an unwelcome influx; urged cooperation.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 39:00 →
OpposedJeremy CherryMar 2, 2026

Warned that immigration policies won the presidency overwhelmingly and council members opposing them face 'a reckoning come election day'; asked where federal non-cooperation stops.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 41:30 →
NeutralUnidentified ResidentMar 2, 2026

Suggested some speakers had misread the ordinance and asked Haynam whether it truly prevents police from cooperating with ICE.

City Council Video — 2026-03-02 · 43:12 →