Missing economic sensitivity study for power plant redevelopment
Summary
A resident argues the ALERG redevelopment plan's 30-year, 100% tax increment financing would divert about $30 million from the school district, and that a rezoning approach would instead require the developer to contribute 20 acres of parkland and preserve school revenue. Council was urged to review the Chapter 1219 overlay provisions before deciding.
At a glance
- Total mentions
- 8
- Last 30 days
- 3
Rising — discussed at 3 meetings since Sep 21, 2026, up from 0 in the two months before.
Impact analysis
City would spend roughly $30 million on land purchase and cleanup under the current plan, with TIF redirecting an estimated $30 million in school revenue.
Under the rezoning alternative Phillips favors, the school district and city park system would benefit.
Under the current TIF plan, the school district would forgo an estimated $30 million in revenue, per the resident's testimony.
Mentions & discussions (7)
City Council — November 9, 2026
The charter amendment requiring voter approval of power-plant development passed narrowly. Supporters vowed continued oversight including scrutiny of the submerged land lease; opponents warned the extra layer of approvals could chill redevelopment. A lakefront visioning meeting was set for November 10.
City Council — November 2, 2026
Rob Shahmir pressed council on a unanimously authorized economic impact and sensitivity analysis agreed to on May 18 — 168 days ago and still not delivered. He said he can't responsibly oppose Issue 36 without the data on what happens if tax revenues fall short.
City Council — September 21, 2026
Former council member Rob Shahmir pushed back on claims that an economic sensitivity analysis would be too costly, saying he produced a back-of-envelope version in three days and that the city needs worst-, base-, and best-case projections before committing to TIFs or CRAs.
City Council — June 1, 2026
Resident Gerald Phillips reported that Metroparks board counsel said there's no board resolution authorizing its director's involvement in the 22-acre power plant site, contradicting what the administration has suggested — and the board won't accept liability for the stack.
City Council — May 18, 2026
Council members Gentry and Shahmir pushed for a third-party economic study before or alongside the zoning vote; a motion requiring it before 1219 failed 3-4, but a unanimous motion will send out RFQs for an economic impact and sensitivity study if 1219 passes.
City Council — February 23, 2026
The massive former power plant site redevelopment hinges on a new mixed-use overlay going to Planning Commission March 3. Shahmir warned there's no infrastructure plan yet, and a resident questioned whether marketing of the site is actually happening.
City Council — February 9, 2026
A resident argues the ALERG redevelopment plan's 30-year, 100% tax increment financing would divert about $30 million from the school district, and that a rezoning approach would instead require the developer to contribute 20 acres of parkland and preserve school revenue. Council was urged to review the Chapter 1219 overlay provisions before deciding.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Avon Lake
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.