Civic Issues
Topics getting the most attention in Avon Lake public meetings, ranked by how frequently they are discussed.
50 issues
Missing economic sensitivity study for power plant redevelopment
A resident argues the ALERG redevelopment plan's 30-year, 100% tax increment financing would divert about $30 million from the school district, and that a rezoning approach would instead require the developer to contribute 20 acres of parkland and preserve school revenue. Council was urged to review the Chapter 1219 overlay provisions before deciding.
Election mailer and campaign conduct allegations
A resident said unposted campaign mailers from the Issue 36 committee may violate federal postal law and questioned their accuracy; another resident urged legal action against the committee treasurer. The committee's treasurer defended the campaign in response.
Income tax collections trending down
RITA collections are down 3.181% through early May — about $255,573 behind — partly due to a volatile taxpayer and a large refund. The city is hoping May deposits close the gap.
Walker Road Phase 6 completion
Council approved going out for bids to pave Walker Road from Jaycox to Lear Road — a long-awaited project. Bonds of about $1.6 million plus a proposed tax increase are part of the funding puzzle.
Flock surveillance contract dispute
Resident Wayne Serra says the city got records showing about 136,030 searches of Avon Lake's cameras in August, with only 90 by Avon Lake police — and disputes the city's claim records can't be searched by plate number. He questions privacy protections and contract compliance.
Deer management program with USDA
A Britannia Estates resident reported deer damage; the city has again contracted the USDA for culling, and residents can weigh in via the ODNR deer survey.
Ozone Garden air quality monitoring project
Fenderbosch's citizen-science project tracks ground-level ozone using NASA's TEMPO satellite, a library air monitor, and Smithsonian bioindicator plants — the full presentation was postponed but a data dashboard is live at ALPL.org.
Ballot Issue 36 — public vote on redevelopment deals
Resident Rob Shahmir asked the city to complete an independent economic sensitivity analysis of the ALERG power plant redevelopment before residents vote on Issue 36, and Gerald Phillips urged a yes vote, arguing the 30-year, $60 million TIF and the 1219 lakefront rezoning would shift costs to taxpayers and the schools. No council action was taken.
Power a Clean Future Ohio membership
Council adopted Resolution 26-91 joining the free sustainability assistance coalition despite resident objections about outside influence and hidden costs. Supporters stressed there are no mandates, no fees, and the Environmental Advisory Board will guide resident involvement.
Power plant redevelopment and TIF financing
A resident argues the ALERG redevelopment plan's 30-year, 100% tax increment financing would divert about $30 million from the school district, and that a rezoning approach would instead require the developer to contribute 20 acres of parkland and preserve school revenue. Council was urged to review the Chapter 1219 overlay provisions before deciding.
Income tax increase (Issue 13) and property tax swap
If voters pass the 0.40% income tax November 3, the 1.5-mill property tax levy ends starting with tax year 2027. Council stressed the swap is tax relief, not a full offset — the income tax funds roads and infrastructure.
Income tax / property tax trade-off
If voters approve the 0.40% income tax on November 3 for roads and storm sewers, council will stop collecting the 1.5-mill property tax levy that funds police, fire, streets and parks starting tax year 2027. Kos told residents it's genuine tax relief, though not a full offset of the income tax.
Electric dirt bikes and off-highway motorcycles
The Public Safety Committee is looking at cracking down on illegal e-motos that hit 50 mph — streamlined definitions, stiffer parental penalties, and police power to confiscate. Expect proposals in November.
City hiring freeze and self-insured health plan
Non-essential hiring is frozen (police and fire exempt) pending budget/levy outcomes, overtime is being limited, and switching to a self-insured health plan for 2027 is expected to save about $700,000.
Employee code of conduct
A draft employee code of conduct went to department directors for feedback, including a social media policy that reaches off-duty conduct — Council Member Kos flagged the slipperiness of regulating employees' off-duty behavior.
2027 Budget and City Finances
Mayor Spaetzel announced a freeze on non-essential hiring — the Engineering Tech II and Urban Forester positions stay open pending the levy and budget outcome — while police and fire essential replacements continue.
Civil service rule changes
The city is paying former Fire Chief Jeremy Betsa $125,000 to end years of litigation. A resident questioned why the deal never appeared publicly before tonight, and Shahmir wants a look at Civil Service Commission procedures going forward.
Legal fees for resident lawsuits
The Mayor revealed legal costs from resident lawsuits exceed $130,000, and the Ohio Supreme Court denied Gerald Phillips's mandamus effort to force the Law Director charter amendment onto the ballot. Council members Kos and Fenderbosch publicly explained their votes on the petitions.
Comprehensive Insurance Renewal Costs
The city's insurance bill jumps 10.5% to $490,150, with lawsuits the city is defending blamed for roughly 4-5 points of that increase and higher water plant valuations for the rest.
City Infrastructure Projects Update
The Electric Boulevard bridge and Walker Road Phase 6 paving should wrap up by October 30 (railing lags to November 30), and pavement marking starts November 2.
Power plant charter amendment and right to vote
A citizen petition would require voter approval before any rezoning or TIF for the former power plant site goes into effect. Council sent it to the November ballot as required by law but passed a resolution urging voters to reject it, warning it could stall redevelopment, kill the planned lakefront park, and push development into B-3 zoning with no public vote.
Boo by the Woods volunteer needs
Council Member Kos announced the October 17 Boo by the Woods event is sold out, but free activities remain, and teen volunteers (14+) are still needed as haunt actors for the Trail of Haunted Tales.
Issue 16 income tax increase for roads and infrastructure
Voters rejected a modest income tax increase meant to fix existing streets, and the city faces an estimated $48 million road repair backlog. Councilmembers squared off over whether the levy's failure should shape how they judge the power plant project.
Fallfest and community celebrations
Council locked in a $32,500 show for July 3, 2026 — the country's 250th birthday — with no general fund money; Friends of the Park and local donations cover it.
Charter amendment on voter review of income tax credits
Council is considering cutting the credit for residents who work outside Avon Lake from 1.5% to 0.5%, raising roughly $6 million a year for roads without raising the 1.5% rate. The mayor wants it on the ballot; critics call it a tax hike without a vote. Second reading July 6, third reading July 13.
ARPA funds spending dispute
A resident accused the city of wasting $2.4 million in COVID relief funds instead of fixing roads. Council members countered that most went to the new Alps park, and Fenderbosch read a detailed breakdown totaling $2.83 million including stormwater, ambulance replacement, and small business grants.
Matthew's Hollow subdivision
Council approved the improvement plan for a 13-lot, 9.35-acre single-family subdivision near Lear and Krebs Roads, clearing the way for new home construction in the R-1A district.
850 Center Road water transmission line property
The city's water utility is buying the old Banjoff farm to run 42-inch transmission mains serving 250,000 customers. It keeps Avon Lake's water rates the lowest in Ohio and leaves most of the 75 acres available for future commercial development near Pinewood Parkway.
Zoning code modernization
Council adopted the first major updates in the zoning code covering subdivisions, site plans, setbacks, fences, driveways and solar equipment height rules — changes recommended by Planning Commission.
Ward 3 and Ward 1 council vacancies
Council went into executive session to interview Ward 3 candidates, and only one application has come in for the Ward 1 seat with a Friday deadline — residents interested in serving need to apply now.
Ward 1 council vacancy after Shahmir's resignation
Amy Gentry resigned effective midnight; resumes are due September 4 and council has about 30 days to appoint her replacement.
The Anchor community center lease
The city says it can't financially justify sponsoring The Anchor, but may end its lease early so the group can start programming and remodeling sooner.
Electric reliability and FirstEnergy outages
A fallen branch that morning knocked out power to roughly a third of the city for about 90 minutes, with about 100 residents still awaiting individual restoration; residents also complained about unusually high July electric bills.
Law Director Charter Amendment and Mandamus Ruling
A second petition would make the Law Director an elected position. It failed to advance 1-6 because counsel found the 2024 and 2026 petitions each fell short of the signature threshold, and council passed a resolution opposing the idea anyway.
Brownfield committee minutes litigation
Gerald Phillips won a 7-0 Ohio Supreme Court ruling forcing the city, CIC and Brownfield Committee to produce meeting minutes from illegal meetings, and an appeals court revived his case seeking the mayor's removal. The city says minutes will be produced within a week.
Police vehicle purchase
Three new police vehicles from Statewide Ford in Van Wert for $131,442 — already budgeted — get first reading Monday.
Composting survey and plastics reduction
A strong composting survey response has the Environmental Advisory Board exploring a citywide composting program, possibly with sustainability grants — no cost to residents is planned.
Tree seedling beautification grant
Up to 18 free tree seedlings will be planted on the safety center property to buffer wind and manage stormwater, with a community planting event before October 8.
State brownfield grant for former power plant site
Verdantis consultant Steve Gross walked council through the VAP process: the Phase One report is nearly done, hundreds of samples have been collected since 2022, and new grant-funded beach and surface-water testing is planned this summer. Full remediation would follow the NFA letter and TIF funding, with an ongoing operations-and-maintenance cost for the engineered cap.
Lorain County urban county CDBG designation
Joining the urban county program could nearly double-and-a-half the county's federal CDBG money and open street, sidewalk and water line grants for a qualifying south Avon Lake neighborhood. Opting out would lock residents out of CHIP and HOME funds once the current state grant cycle ends in 2027.
Anchor facility memorandum of understanding
Shahmir publicly aired that a Cleveland Clinic facility considered Towne Center but fell through, and he never heard about it as committee chair; the Mayor said only rumors were known and private negotiations weren't the city's business.
Harbor Crest Townhouse Subdivision No. 1
A two-day, open-cut trench crossing of Route 83 next week for a water main connection. Two lanes of traffic should stay open, with message boards and school bus garage coordination.
Portside/Liberty Rose stormwater flooding
A resident reported repeated flooding over the July 4 weekend despite cleaned drains, blaming design and maintenance, and asked the city to seek cost recovery and hold Pulte accountable.
Job growth incentive plan sunset
Council is obligated to hand out about $155,559 in tax-year-2025 business awards, but members want to reshape or end the program and ask large recipients to donate awards toward economic development.
Low-speed vehicle (golf cart) regulation
Council is drafting rules to let golf carts on 25 mph streets with registration, licensed drivers, and safety inspections — full three readings expected before spring.
Property maintenance enforcement practices
A resident described an unsigned violation notice with no inspection date or appeal process and alleged the inspector entered her property without permission; she's asking for transparency and a review of the notices.
Bald eagles at the former power plant site
A resident reported five bald eagles at the ALERG/coal plant site and asked whether their protected status could complicate the 1,200-unit redevelopment; the Environmental Committee will investigate.
Heider Creek culvert replacement
The bridge flagged by ODOT inspections needs replacing; American Structurepoint gets up to ~$158,727 for design work, with OPWC funding for construction.
Fire Chief and Assistant Chief Job Descriptions
A fire captain retires in August, and the fire chief/assistant chief job descriptions still need fixing before council can act — council members are pushing for speed.
Delwood Tree Hazards and Power Outages
Dead trees near Redwood School are falling into yards and taking out power lines — one narrowly missed a resident in her pool. Another resident, a retired Con Edison utility worker, described dangling transformers and 34-hour outages.