Civic Issues
Topics getting the most attention in Avon Lake public meetings, ranked by how frequently they are discussed.
23 issues in taxes budget
Income tax collections trending down
RITA collections are down 3.181% through early May — about $255,573 behind — partly due to a volatile taxpayer and a large refund. The city is hoping May deposits close the gap.
Election mailer and campaign conduct allegations
A resident said unposted campaign mailers from the Issue 36 committee may violate federal postal law and questioned their accuracy; another resident urged legal action against the committee treasurer. The committee's treasurer defended the campaign in response.
Missing economic sensitivity study for power plant redevelopment
A resident argues the ALERG redevelopment plan's 30-year, 100% tax increment financing would divert about $30 million from the school district, and that a rezoning approach would instead require the developer to contribute 20 acres of parkland and preserve school revenue. Council was urged to review the Chapter 1219 overlay provisions before deciding.
Income tax increase (Issue 13) and property tax swap
If voters pass the 0.40% income tax November 3, the 1.5-mill property tax levy ends starting with tax year 2027. Council stressed the swap is tax relief, not a full offset — the income tax funds roads and infrastructure.
City hiring freeze and self-insured health plan
Non-essential hiring is frozen (police and fire exempt) pending budget/levy outcomes, overtime is being limited, and switching to a self-insured health plan for 2027 is expected to save about $700,000.
Income tax / property tax trade-off
If voters approve the 0.40% income tax on November 3 for roads and storm sewers, council will stop collecting the 1.5-mill property tax levy that funds police, fire, streets and parks starting tax year 2027. Kos told residents it's genuine tax relief, though not a full offset of the income tax.
Employee code of conduct
A draft employee code of conduct went to department directors for feedback, including a social media policy that reaches off-duty conduct — Council Member Kos flagged the slipperiness of regulating employees' off-duty behavior.
2027 Budget and City Finances
Mayor Spaetzel announced a freeze on non-essential hiring — the Engineering Tech II and Urban Forester positions stay open pending the levy and budget outcome — while police and fire essential replacements continue.
Legal fees for resident lawsuits
The Mayor revealed legal costs from resident lawsuits exceed $130,000, and the Ohio Supreme Court denied Gerald Phillips's mandamus effort to force the Law Director charter amendment onto the ballot. Council members Kos and Fenderbosch publicly explained their votes on the petitions.
Comprehensive Insurance Renewal Costs
The city's insurance bill jumps 10.5% to $490,150, with lawsuits the city is defending blamed for roughly 4-5 points of that increase and higher water plant valuations for the rest.
Issue 16 income tax increase for roads and infrastructure
Voters rejected a modest income tax increase meant to fix existing streets, and the city faces an estimated $48 million road repair backlog. Councilmembers squared off over whether the levy's failure should shape how they judge the power plant project.
Charter amendment on voter review of income tax credits
Council is considering cutting the credit for residents who work outside Avon Lake from 1.5% to 0.5%, raising roughly $6 million a year for roads without raising the 1.5% rate. The mayor wants it on the ballot; critics call it a tax hike without a vote. Second reading July 6, third reading July 13.
ARPA funds spending dispute
A resident accused the city of wasting $2.4 million in COVID relief funds instead of fixing roads. Council members countered that most went to the new Alps park, and Fenderbosch read a detailed breakdown totaling $2.83 million including stormwater, ambulance replacement, and small business grants.
Ward 3 and Ward 1 council vacancies
Council went into executive session to interview Ward 3 candidates, and only one application has come in for the Ward 1 seat with a Friday deadline — residents interested in serving need to apply now.
Law Director Charter Amendment and Mandamus Ruling
A second petition would make the Law Director an elected position. It failed to advance 1-6 because counsel found the 2024 and 2026 petitions each fell short of the signature threshold, and council passed a resolution opposing the idea anyway.
Brownfield committee minutes litigation
Gerald Phillips won a 7-0 Ohio Supreme Court ruling forcing the city, CIC and Brownfield Committee to produce meeting minutes from illegal meetings, and an appeals court revived his case seeking the mayor's removal. The city says minutes will be produced within a week.
Lorain County urban county CDBG designation
Joining the urban county program could nearly double-and-a-half the county's federal CDBG money and open street, sidewalk and water line grants for a qualifying south Avon Lake neighborhood. Opting out would lock residents out of CHIP and HOME funds once the current state grant cycle ends in 2027.
Finance Director Resignation and Interim Coverage
Beth Krosse — widely praised for transparency and the May income tax levy campaign — leaves July 29. The mayor wants an ordinance Monday to keep her on part-time while the city searches for a replacement.
Property tax repeal commitment
If the income tax passes, Council says it will discontinue the 1.5-mill property tax starting tax year 2026 — worth about $1.1 million a year back to property owners. Residents warned that a 'whereas' clause isn't legally binding and demanded a binding repeal resolution.
May 2026 income tax levy proposal
Voters will decide May 5 on a 0.4% income tax levy that, if passed, would replace the city's current 1.5-mill property tax levy. An info session is set for March 11 at the library.
Walker Road / SR-83 TIF clarification
Residents were confused about who pays and who benefits from the TIF at Walker Road and Route 83. The mayor clarified it's a residential TIF for the Sand Ridge and Harbor Crest developments, schools are made whole, and the developer gets nothing — proceeds can only bond out intersection improvements.
Erieview Elementary building purchase
The school board signed the purchase agreement; the city hopes to close this week, with a lingering lien and salvaged building systems for fire safety the last two sticking points.
2026 Council Leadership and Committee Structure
Council set its leadership for the next two years — Jeff Smith as president and David Kos as pro tem — and divided committee work across seven standing committees. Committee chairs shape which issues get attention and how fast.